Vicarious Liability of State
Keywords:
Vicarious Lability of State, Respondeat Superior, Qui facit per alium facit per se, Socialisation of Damages, Tortious liability, Sovereign and Non-Sovereign function, Statutes.Abstract
This article deals with the Vicarious Liability of the State in Law of Torts. The word ‘administration’ is used here synonymously with ‘State’ or ‘Government’. How far the administration would be liable for the torts committed by its servants is an intricate problem especially in developing countries with ever widening State activities. The liability of the Government in tort is administered by the principles of public law inherited from British Common Law and the provisions of The Constitution of India, 1950. It notably focuses on the recognition of the liability in case of legal injury and providing damages to the individuals especially by the Judiciary. The scope of the article is very limited to assess the extent of tortious liability before the Constitution and the gradual changes in approach in post-Constitutional era. The hypothesis that is outlined is considered or not considered to be tortious liability that undergone major changes and the Court have explored new dimensions of liability to provide remedies and compensate victim of state action. The Article is all about the tortious liability of the State and it explains the Pre-Constitutional and Post-Constitutional judicial decisions along with the case laws and it also talks about the sovereign functions and non-sovereign functions before and after the enforcement Constitution. Finally, this article deals with the Doctrine of Public Accountability in the field of judicial and personal liability in comparison to both English and Indian Laws. It also deals with the statutes that are bound by the state, whereby it includes comparisons with the English and Indian Law.References
1. http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/580/Vicarious-Liability-of-State-in-Sovereign- Functions.html, visited on July 12, 2021
2. https://www.lawctopus.com/academike/vicarious-liability-state/ , visited on July 15, 2021
3. https://lexlife.in/2020/05/13/law-of-torts-vicarious-liability-of-state/, visited on July 14, 2021
4. Law of Torts by Dr. R.K. Bangia Revised by Dr. Narender Kumar (24th Edition, 2017) Publisher- Allahabad Law Agency
5. Entick Vs Carrington, (1765) 19 St. Tr 1030
6. Royster versus Cavey, AIR 1947 K.B. 204
7. Crown Proceedings Act, 1947
8. The Law of Torts by Ratanlal & Dhirajlal (28th Edition) Publisher – Lexis Nexis
9. Constitution of India, 1950
10. Government of India Act, 1858
11. Nobin Chander Dey Vs Secretary of State for India, ILR 1 Cal. 11
12. P. and O.S.N. Co.'s, (1861) 5 Bom. H.C.R. App. I, p1
13. The Secretary of State for India in Council vs Hari Bhanji, (1882) ILR 5 Mad 273
14. Kasturi Lal vs State of U.P., AIR 1965 SC 1039
15. Indian Insurance Co. Association Pool Vs Radhabai, AIR 1978 MP 164
16. Pagadala Narasimham Vs The Commissioner and Special Officer, Nellore Municipality , AIR 1994
17. State of Orissa Vs Padmalochan, AIR 1975
18. State of Punjab Vs Lal Chand Sabharwal, AIR 1975
19. Negligence by CARSWELL PUBLISHERS
20. Baxi Amrik Singh Vs the Union of India, AIR 1973
21. State of Punjab Vs Lal Chand Sabharwal AIR 1975
22. Smt. Jasso Vs Union of India AIR 1962 Punjab 315
23. Union of India Vs Abdul Rehman, 1981 J K 60
24. The Law of Torts and Consumer Protection Act by M.N. Shukla
25. State of U.P. Vs Hindustan Lever Ltd.AIR 1972 All 486
26. State of M.P. Vs Shantabai, 2005 A.C.J 313 (M.P.)
27. State of Gujarat Vs Memon Mohamed, AIR 1967 S.C. 1885
28. H.S.E.B. Vs Ram Nath, 2005 A.C.J. 342 (SC)
29. Dharanidhar Panda Vs State of Orissa, 2006 A.C.J. 487 (Ori.)
30. State of A.P. Vs M/S J.K. Traders, 2011 (NOC) 225
31. People’s Union for Democratic Rights Vs State of Bihar, AIR 1987 S.C. 355
32. State of Gujarat Vs Govindbhai, 1999 Guj. 316
33. Ramjan Vs State of Rajasthan, 2008 (NOC) 2168 (Raj.)
34. D.K. Basu Vs State of West Bengal, 1997 S.C. 610
35. Common Cause- A Registered Society V Union of India, 1999 S.C. 2979
36. N. Nagender Rao Vs State of A.P. 1994 S.C. 2663
37. State of Rajasthan Vs Vidyawati 1962 S.C. 933
38. Kasturi Lal Vs State of U.P. 1965 S.C. 1039
