Reconciling Trademark Infringement and the Tort of Passing Off in Cameroon: A Legal Appraisal
Keywords:
Reconciling, Trademark, Infringement, Passing Off.Abstract
This paper unveils the concept of trademark infringement and the tort of passing off under intellectual property rights by reviewing the Cameroonian perspective on the same. It evaluates the scope of protection accorded to holders of registered and unregistered marks and signs in Cameroon. The paper adopts a qualitative research methodology based on the doctrinal and content analysis of primary and secondary data. The study documents that owners of registered trade or service marks have been extensively sheltered under the law in force, while users or owners of unregistered marks or signs remain vulnerable in cases of illicit use by unauthorized third parties, since the range of protection is limited with no statutory shield. The researcher recommends that policies and statutory
shields be established to protect the ingenuity of unregistered mark holders and the reputation of goods sold under the name and style of such marks.
References
1. Bryan A Garner. Black’s Law dictionary 11th edition (Thomas Reuters, United States of America 2019) p963.
2. Bently, L et al: Intellectual property law 4th edition, Oxford University Press 198 Madison Avenue, New York,NY 10016,United States Of America 2014.
3. Aplin, T et al. Intellectual property law: Text,cases and materials .Third edition Oxford University Press 198 Madison Avenue,New York, vNY 10016,United States Of America January 2017.
4. Section 330, Law No 2016/007 of 12 July 2016, instituting the Penal code of the republic of Cameroon.
5. Article 57, annex iii of the Bangui Accord of 1977 as amended.
6. Cornish, W & David, L. Intellectual Property : Patents, Copyrights, Trademarks and Allied rights. Fifth Edition (Sweets and Maxwell limited :100 Avenue Road swiss Cottage London, NW3 3PF, 2003) p593.
7. Article 2(1) annex iii of the Bangui Accord 1977 as amended.
8. Article 2(1) (a) annex iii (a),(b),(c) of the Bangui Accord 1977 as amended
9. Article 2 (2) annex iii bangui accord 1977 as amended defines a collective mark as as a mark of products or services whose conditions of use have been laid down in rules approved by the competent authority and which may be used only by public enterprises, unions or groups of unions, associations, groups, groups of producers, manufacturers, craftmen or trademen in circumstances wherein they are officially recongnised and have lrgal personality.
10. Article 3 (a),(b),(c),(d), (e) of the Bangui Accord 1977 as amended.
11. Article 4 (1) (2) of the Bangui accord 1977 as amended.
12. Article 6 of the Bangui accord 1977 as amended.
13. Article 49 of the Bangui accord 1977 as amended.
14. Section 330 (1) & (2), Law No 2016/007 of 12 July 2016,instituting the Penal code of the republic of Cameroon.
15. Op cit note 6.
16. Article 55 (1),(2),(3) of the Bangui Accord 1977 as amended.
17. CPTE No 920/P/16/08/07/16 (Unreported)
18. Judgment No 499/COM of 01 November 2016, High Court of Wouri Division.
19. Article 4 annex iii of the Bangui accord 1977 as amended & Section 330 (1) & (2), Law No 2016/007 of 12 July 2016, instituting the Penal code of the republic of Cameroon.
20. Abbe, B et al: Contemporary Intellectual Property Law and Policy.fIfth edition, Oxford University Press 198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America 2019.
21. Perry v Truefitt (1842).6 Beav 66,49 E.R.749.
22. Eddie Irine V.Talk ltd (2003)EMLR 538
23. Cornish, W & David, L. Intellectual Property: Patents, Copyrights, Trademarks and Allied rights. Fifth Edition, (Sweets and Maxwell limited :100 Avenue Road swiss Cottage London,NW3 3PF, 2003) pp.593-599
24. British diabetic society v. Diabetic society [1996] EWCA Civ 839
25. Reckitt & Colman products Ltd v Borden Inc [1990] 1 All E.R.873.
26. [1979] AC 731, [1980] R.P.C 31.
27. Suit No CASWR/17C/2011. ENDNOTE (i) This law is essentially an agreement between sixteen West and Central African Countries to create a regional IP system. Amongst these Countries include Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Congo. Central African Republic, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Guinea Conakry, Guinea Bissau, Mauritania, Mali, Senegal, Niger, Tchad and Togo. (ii) Article 2 annex iii of the Bangui Accord 1977 as amended defines a trademark/service mark as any visible sign, which has been used or it’s intended to be used and its capable of distinguishing goods or services of any Natural or Artificial Person. (iii) An essential condition (iv) Passing off which applies to the misrepresentation of a particular quality of a product. (v) Passing off which occurs when a Party kills or eliminates the Original Trademark on a Product and sells the said product without permission or his/her brand.
