RIFT AT TOYOTA-KIRLOSKAR PLANT: A RECURRENT HISTORY OF LABOUR UNREST
Keywords:
Toyota Kirloskar Plant, Strikes, Temporary Workers, Occupational Safety, Hire & FireAbstract
The Toyota Kirloskar Manufacturing Unit situated in Karnataka made headlines in the month
of November 2020 after the workers of the plant declared strike which was followed by a
lockout by the management and the bust-up went on for about four long months. However,
the pertinent question is whether it is the first instance of labour unrest at this plant, or is it
a periodic custom at this plant? Since its inception (1997-1998), the Toyota Manufacturing
Unit has experienced numerous strikes and lockouts by the workers and management,
respectively. The Toyota Production System, that guides the manufacturing process of all
Toyota Plants globally, practices a rigorous control over its workers undermining
occupational safety and has often been described as inhumane by the researchers. On a
closer analysis the main issues behind all the instances of labour unrest involve better
conditions at work, contractualisation and better wages. The State Government has often
favoured the company through low-interest loans, relaxed pollution control norms, etc.,
turning a blind eye to the labour conditions. In the wake of international and domestic
Labour Unions’ pressure, the management reluctantly tried to resolve the disputes in order to resume the work. However, considering the present strike, it seems that the resolutions
were merely a band-aid solution and, the management failed to address the root cause of
the problem over the years.
This paper presents an analysis of the blatant violations of International Conventions and
domestic laws by the management of the Toyota Kirloskar Manufacturing Unit that paints
an abysmal picture of labour conditions.
References
1. Saiyed HN and Tiwari RR, “Occupational Health Research in India” 42 Industrial Health 141
2. “Safety and Health Information” [2012] Directorate General, Factory Advice Service and Labour Institutes (DGFASLI), Ministry of Labour and Employment, Government of India (GoI)
3. “Mental Health Policies and Programmes in the Workplace” World Health Organisation
4. Elliot I, “Poverty and Mental Health: A Review to Inform the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s Anti- Poverty Strategy” [2016] London: Mental Health Foundation.
5. Swamy R, “Not Just Wistron Karnataka Battling Tougher Longer Crisis at Toyota Kirloskar Plant” The Print (December 24, 2020) <https://theprint.in/india/not -just-wistron-karnataka-battling- tougher-longer-labour-crisis-at-toyota-kirloskar-plant/572811/> accessed May 24, 2021
6. HR News Bureau, “4-Month Strike at Toyota Plant in Karnataka Ends Officially” HR Katha (March 3, 2021) accessed May 24, 2021
7. Business Line Bureau, “Toyota Employees’ Strike: Management, Union Still at Loggerheads” The Hindu (December 21, 2020) <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/companies/toyota - employees-strike-management-union-still-at-loggerheads/article33387158.ece > accessed May 26, 2021
8. Suresh H, “Ground Report: 37 Days in, Why Toyota Kirloskar Workers in Bidadi Continue to Protest” The NewsMinute (December 15, 2020) <https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/ground- report-37-days-why-toyota-kirloskar-workers-bidadi-continue-protest-139649 > accessed May 26, 2021
9. “Toyota India Hires Contract Workers to Restart Output” LiveMint (March 26, 2014) <https://www.livemint.com/Companies/FHFBFmXOmPBgScEfK1CORM/Toyota-India-hires- contract-workers-to-restart-output.html> accessed May 27, 2021
10. Pedulla DS, “The Hidden Costs of Contingency: Employers' Use of Contingent Workers and Standard Employees' Outcomes” (2013) 92 Social Forces 691
11. Hiatt JP, “Policy Issues Concerning the Contingent Work Force” (1995) 52 Wash. & Lee L. Rev 739
12. Gottfried H, “In the Margins: Flexibility as a Mode of Regulation in the Temporary Help Service Industry” (1992) 6 Work, Employment and Society 443
13. Vough HC, Joseph PB and Gregory BN, “Here Today, Gone Tomorrow? Effects of Nonstandard Work Status on Workgro up Processes and Outcomes” (2005) 7 Status and Groups: Research on Managing Groups and Teams 229
14. Wacquant L, “Punishing The Poor: The Neoliberal Government Of Social Insecurity” [2009] Duke University Press
15. Fumio K, “Toyota and Asia Automobile Workers’ in Labour in Globalising Asian Corporations: A Portrait of Struggle, Asian TNC Monitoring Network Series” [2006] AMRC 181
16. George S, “Lockout at Toyota -Kirloskar: The Future Space for Labour” [2014] Economic and Political Weekly 18
17. “Tripartite Consultation (International Labour Standards) Convention” (1976)
18. “Collective Bargaining Convention” (1981) RIFT At Toyota-Kirloskar Plant Priya and Nayan
19. “Toyota Kirloskar Suspends 39 Union Members As Strike at Bidadi Plant Continue” BLOOMBERGQUINT (November 13, 2020) <https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/toyota - kirloskar-suspends-39-union-members-as-strike-at-bidadi-plant-continues> accessed May 28, 2021
20. Mathew S and Burgess J, “Lean Production, Izzat and Industrial Conflict in the Indian Auto Sector: A Case Study” (2018) 73 Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 541
21. Tripartite Declaration of Principles concerning Multinational Enterprises and Social Policy, art. 59, Nov. 1977, https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_emp/---emp_ent/---multi/documents/ publication/wcms_094386.pdf.
22. George S, “Lockout at Toyota -Kirloskar: The Future Space for Labour” [2014] Economic and Political Weekly 18
23. Shrivastava S, “Organisational Justice: A Senian Perspective” (2016) 135 Journal of Business Ethics 99 accessed March 28, 2021
24. United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (Geneva), “Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment: A Global Survey” ASIT Advisory Studies No. 16.
25. George S, “Lockout at Toyota -Kirloskar: The Future Space for Labour” [2014] Economic and Political Weekly 18
26. Swamy R, “Not Just Wistron Karnataka Battling Tougher Longer Crisis at Toyota Kirloskar Plant” The Print (December 24, 2020) <https://theprint.in/india/not -just-wistron-karnataka-battling- tougher-longer-labour-crisis-at-toyota-kirloskar-plant/572811/> accessed May 24, 2021
27. Supra note 32 at page 107.
28. The Essential Service Maintenance Act 1981
29. Supra note 34 at page 109.
30. Abreu ARP, Beynon H and Ramalho JR, “The Dream Factory’: VW’s Modular Production System in Resende, Brazil” (2000) 14 Work, Employment and Society 265
31. Coe NM, Jones K and Ward K, “The Business of Temporary Staffing: a Developing Research Agenda” (2010) 4 Geography Compass 1055
32. Davidov G, “Joint Employer Status in Triangular Employment Relationships” (2004) 42 British
33. Elcioglu EF, “Producing Precarity: the Temporary Staffing Agency in the Labor Market” (2010) 33 Qualitative Sociology 117
34. Fumio K, “Toyota and Asia Automobile Workers’ in Labour in Globalising Asian Corporations: A Portrait of Struggle, Asian TNC Monitoring Network Series” [2006] AMRC 181
35. George S, “Lockout at Toyota -Kirloskar: The Future Space for Labour” [2014] Economic and Political Weekly 18
36. Gottfried H, “In the Margins: Flexibility as a Mode of Regulation in the Temporary Help Service Industry” (1992) 6 Work, Employment and Society 443
37. Hiatt JP, “Policy Issues Concerning the Contingent Work Force” (1995) 52 Wash. & Lee L. Rev 739
38. Mathew S and Burgess J, “Lean Production, Izzat and Industrial Conflict in the Indian Auto Sector: A Case Study” (2018) 73 Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 541
39. Peck J and Theodore N, “Contingent Chicago: Restructuring the Spaces of Temporary Labor” (2001) 25 International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 471
40. Peck J, Theodore N and Ward K, “Constr ucting Markets for Temporary Labour: Employment Liberalization and the Internationalization of the Staffing Industry” (2005) 5 Global Networks 3
41. Pedulla DS, “The Hidden Costs of Contingency: Employers' Use of Contingent Workers and Standard Employees' Outcomes” (2013) 92 Social Forces 691
42. Vosko LF, “Temporary Work: The Gendered Rise of a Precarious Employment Relationship” [2000] University of Toronto Press
43. Vough HC, Joseph PB and Gregory BN, “Here Today, Gone Tomorrow? Effects of Nonstandard Work Status on Workgroup Processes and Outcomes” (2005) 7 Status and Groups: Research on Managing Groups and Teams 229
44. Wacquant L, “Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity” [2009] Duke University Press
45. Ward K, “Making Manchester ‘Flexible ’: Competition and Change in the Temporary Staffing Industry” (2005) 36 Geoforum 223
