Transfer Pricing: A Tool for Abusive Tax Avoidance?
Keywords:
Transfer Pricing, MNCs, Intellectual Property, Taxation, Tax AvoidanceAbstract
Multinational corporations and enterprises have started to increasingly operate as internationally integrated networks. They engage in aggressive global tax, planning to greatly reduce their total tax liabilities worldwide. They are able to transfer revenues to foreign affiliates with lower corporate tax rates. The most shocking tax avoidance has taken place in the transfer pricing manipulation of intellectual property and in relocation of intellectual property. Such abusive tax avoidance has unfairly drained significant tax revenue from many countries and has created an enormous challenge for the global economy.
This paper discusses the complexity of transfer pricing issues in relation to intellectual property issues, such as, the registration of intellectual property, their commercial realities, the challenges in their valuation and the accounting tax concerns that arise with it. It also addresses the abusive tax avoidance problem that is seen at the present time and the consequential growth of transfer pricing regulations worldwide and the prescribed valuation approach for transfer pricing of intellectual property.
It concludes by proposing legal reforms to reduce abusive tax avoidance and that Multinational corporations support the international legal reforms, because the Multinational corporations have severely undermined their credibility of being good corporate citizens who pay their fair share of taxes, with the host countries. If the Multinational corporations start to fully comply with the reforms that are proposed and utilize appropriate transfer prices to reflect the economic realities of their related-party transactions, they could restore their credibility with both the public as well as the government regulators.
This would solve the enormous challenge faced by the global economies and favorably regulate the climate for international business transactions.
Keywords: Transfer Pricing, MNCs, Intellectual Property, Taxation, Tax Avoidance.
References
1. Michael Alles , Srikant Datar, ‘Strategic Transfer Pricing’, (1998) 44 MGMT. SCI 451, https://ideas.repec.org/a/inm/ormnsc/ v44y1998i4p451-461.html, accessed on 19th September 2019.
2. Robert A. Leitch , Kevin S. Barrett, ‘Multinational Transfer Pricing: Objectives and Constraints’, (1992) 11 J. Acct. Literature 47, https://search. proquest.com/docview/216305261?pq- origsite=gscholar, accessed on 19th September 2019.
3. Vagts, ‘The Multinational Enterprise: A New Challenge for Transnational Law’, (1970) 83 Harv. L. Rev. 739, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1339838?casa _token=nKLr4eshZMgAAAAA:HruBOG bkHPXvL79zYUeXIM4su1jO_6Z0dm0G aAlhf8ofJhS_Ba4g9YgcPXIVHJOOw7CP zGARupdd51TNki4t9uLFLXNjjdpoAzm YlJr5cFSImRDh78Yf&seq=1#metadata_i nfo_tab_contents, accessed on 19th September 2019.
4. Bob Ackerman, ‘Global Transfer Pricing Update’, (2005) 37 TAX INT’L 469,
5. Robert J. Cunningham, ‘The Future of International Transfer Pricing: Practical and Policy Opportunities Unique to Intellectual Property Foreign Transfer Pricing Audits’, (2002) 10 GEO. MASON L. REV. 697, https://heinonline.org/ HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/ gmlr10&div=36&id=&page=, accessed on 20th September 2019.
6. Larry Franko, ‘The International Tax Showdown’, (1994) 20 INT’L TAX J. 12, https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage? handle=hein.journals/intaxjo20&div=26&i d=&page=, accessed on 19th September 2019.
7. David Harris, ‘Income Shifting in US Multinational Corporations’, (1993) 1 INT’L TAX J. 277, http://www.nber.org/ chapters/c8001, accessed on 17th September 2019.
8. Robert Ackerman & Elizabeth Chorvat, ‘Modern Financial Theory and Transfer Pricing’, (2002) 10 GEO. MASON L. REV. 637, https://heinonline.org/HOL/ LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/gmlr1 0&div=34&id=&page=, accessed on 20th September 2019.
9. Steven Filling & Prem Sikka, ‘Taxing the Boundaries of Corporate Social Reporting’, (2004) 33 PUB. INT. 21.
10. Stanley J. Langbein, ‘Transfer Pricing and the Outsourcing Problem’, (2005) Int’l Tax L. Rev. 1299.
11. Russ O’Haver, ‘Improving Deals with Transfer Pricing’, (2004) 5 Int’l Tax L. Rev.
12. Vagts. The Multinational Enterprise: A New Challenge for Transnational Law’, (1970) 83 Harv. L. Rev. 739, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1339838?casa _token=nKLr4eshZMgAAAAA:HruBOG Transfer Pricing: A Tool for Abusive Tax Avoidance? Pranathi Karuturi JTRF (2020) 23–31 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 30 bkHPXvL79zYUeXIM4su1jO_6Z0dm0G aAlhf8ofJhS_Ba4g9YgcPXIVHJOOw7CP zGARupdd51TNki4t9uLFLXNjjdpoAzm YlJr5cFSImRDh78Yf&seq=1#metadata_i nfo_tab_contents, accessed on 19th September 2019.
13. Elizabeth Chorvat, ‘You Can’t Take It with You: Behavioral Finance and Corporate Expatriation’, (2003) 37 U.C. Davis L. REV. 453, https://heinonline.org/ HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/ davlr37&div=24&id=&page=, accessed on 21st September 2019.
14. Tommy S. Gabrielsen & Guttorm Schjelderup, ‘Transfer Pricing and Ownership Structure’, (1999) 101 SCAN. J. OF ECON. 673, https://onlinelibrary. wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1467-9442.0 0179, accessed on 22nd September 2019.
15. Eric J. Bartlesman & Roel M. W. J. Beetsman, ‘Why Pay More?: Corporation Tax Avoidance Through Transfer Pricing OECD Countries’, (2003) 87 OF PUB. ECON. 2225, https://www.sciencedirect. com/science/article/abs/pii/S00472727020 0018X, accessed on 22nd September 2019.
16. Brown, ‘A Consideration of Selected Issues Relating to United States Taxation of International Transfers of Information and Other Intellectual Property’, (1991) 17 Brooklyn J. INT’L 16, https:// heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle =hein.journals/bjil17&div=9&id=&page=, accessed on 23nd September 2019.
17. Lorriane Eden, ‘Standards Across Borders: Cross border Diffusion of the Arm’s Length Standard in North America’, (2001) 26 ACCT. ORG. & SOC’Y 1, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti cle/pii/S0361368299000628, accessed on 22nd September 2019.
18. R. Micheal Gadbaw, ‘Intellectual Property and International Trade: Merger or Marriage of Convenience?’, (1989) 22 Vand. J. Transn’l L. 223, https:// heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle =hein.journals/vantl22&div=14&id=&pag e=, accessed on 23rd September 2019.
19. Martin Przysuski, ‘Transactional Profit Methods: A Practitioner’s Response to the OECD’, (2006) 43 TAX NOTES INT’L 725,
20. Robert J. Cunningham, ‘The Future of International Transfer Pricing: Practical and Policy Opportunities Unique to Intellectual Property Foreign Transfer Pricing Audits’, (2002) 10 GEO. MASON L. REV. 697, https://heinonline. org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journ als/gmlr10&div=36&id=&page=, accessed on 20th September 2019.
21. Sanjay Sanghvi, ‘India to Sign Protocol Amending Tax Treaty with Italy”, (2005) 40 Tax Mgmt. Transfer Pricing Rep. 610
22. Alberto Varela, ‘Uruguay: Tax Reform Proposal Preserves Source-Based Taxation’, (2006) 43 TAX NOTES INT’L 976.
23. Mark Freer and Greda Brand, ‘New Transfer Pricing, Thin Capitalization Rules Take Effect’, (2005) 39 TAX NOTES INT’L 1155, https://journals. sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0032329216 655316, accessed on 27th September 2019.
24. Gregory J. Ossi, ‘The Search for Consistency: A Global Approach to Transfer Pricing Documentaries’, (2003) 1 TAX MGMT. INT’L J. 283
25. R. Micheal Gadbaw, ‘Intellectual Property and International Trade: Merger or Marriage of Convenience?’, (1989) 22 VAND. J. TRANSN’L L. 223, https:// heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle =hein.journals/vantl22&div=14&id=&pag e=, accessed on 23rd September 2019.
26. Rom P Watson, 'New Developments in Transfer Pricing Rules' (1991) 17 Brook J Int'l L 61, https://heinonline.org/HOL/ LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/bjil17 &div=10&id=&page=, accessed on 27th September 2019.
27. Thomas C Pearson, 'Proposed International Legal Reforms for Reducing Transfer Pricing Manipulation of Intellectual Property ' (2008) 40 NYU J Int'l L & POL 541, https://heinonline. org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journ als/nyuilp40&div=18&id=&page=, accessed on 28th September 2019
28. Ambar J., ‘Transfer Pricing, Important Developments During the Year: Transfer Pricing’, (2003) 56 Tax Lawyer 1201
29. Drew Douglas, Transfer Pricing Top Priority as IRS Plans Release of International Guidance, (2006) 14 BNA JTRF (2020) 23–31 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 31 TAX MGMT. TRANSFER PICING REP. 798
30. Elena R. Tsaneva, Transfer Pricing in the World of Services and Intangibles -A New Challenge to Preserving the Corporate Tax Base, (2004) 9 UCLAJ. INT'L L. & FOREIGN AFF. 323, https://heinonline. org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journ als/jilfa9&div=14&id=&page=, accessed on 29th September 2019.
31. Gregory J. Ossi, ‘The Search for Consistency: A Global Approach to Transfer Pricing Documentaries’, (2003) 1 TAX MGMT. INT’L J. 283
32. Martin Przysuski, ‘Identification, Innovation, and Intangible Ownership in Transfer Pricing’, (2004) 42 TAX NOTES INT'L 1139
33. Keith Reams, ‘Proposed U.S. Cost - Sharing Regulations: Are They a Realistic Alternative?’, (2005) 40 TAX NOTES INT'L 269, https://www.taxinstitute.com. au/77861601-EBDB-6A57-8CD537C69 6DD2384 accessed on 29th September 2019
34. Michael J. McIntyre, The Use of Combined Reporting by Nation States, (2004) 35 TAX NOTES INT'L 917, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Th e-Use-of-Combined-Reporting-By-Nation- States-McIntyre/74de0d21fe1730f34b9b 8e37ae470de6cf6750a6 accessed on 29th September 2019.
35. Thomas C. Pearson, ‘State Taxation of Foreign Source Income through Worldwide Combined Reporting’, (1984) 17 VAND. J. TRANSNAT’l L. 95, https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage? handle=hein.journals/vantl17&div=16&id =&page=, accessed on 1st October 2019
36. Charles E. McLure, ‘U.S. Federal Use of Formula Apportionment to Tax Income from In -tangibles’, (1997) 75 TAX NOTES TODAY 109
37. Thomas C. Pearson & Dennis R. Schmidt, ‘Transfer Pricing Tax Concerns for Global Financial Companies’, (1998) 76 TAXES 23, https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPa ge?handle=hein.journals/taxtm76&div=89 &id=&page=, accessed on 1st October 2019.
38. Joe Kirwin & Mitchell J. Tropin, ‘EC Proposes Home State SME Pilot: Program Would Use Formulary Apportionment’, (2006) 14 BNA TAX MGMT. TRANSFER PRICING REP. 734 Cite this Article Pranathi Karuturi. Transfer Pricing: A Tool for Abusive Tax Avoidance? Journal of Taxation and Regulatory Framework. 2020; 3(2): 23–31p.
