Limiting Human Rights in the Face of Pandemics? Examining this Question through the Covid-19 Prism
Keywords:
COVID-19 pandemic, emergency, human rights law, limiting human rightsAbstract
Pandemics such as COVID-19 are dreaded occurrences that often put human rights at peril since it threatens the existence of the humanity. Stemming them usually require urgent response that could jeopardize the protection and promotion of human rights. While pandemics have direct impact on the right to health and right to life, their management could equally result to unlawful violation of other human rights if not well thought out. The purpose of this paper is to examine how Corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) affects human rights and freedoms around the globe and the extent to which states restrict these rights under Human Rights Law. The finding reveals that balancing the pendulum between curbing the spread of COVID-19 and respecting human rights is an uphill task. However, minimizing political overtones in the efforts while prioritizing legal foundations could enhance the management.
References
1. Australian Government , Department of Health. What you need to know about coronavirus (COVID -19). Available online at: , (last accessed on 19th May, 2020).
2. Shrikrushna Subhash Unhale et al. A review on corona virus (COVID-19). World Journal of Pharm aceutical and Life Sciences (WJPLS). 2020; 6(4): 109–115.
3. Sarah Yerkes . (2020). Coronavirus, threatens freedom in Northern Africa Garnegie Endowment for International Peace. Available online at: , (last accessed on 19th May, 2020).
4. The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner and Inter - Parliamentary Union . (2016). Human Rights: Handbook for Parliamentarians No. 26 (IPU and OHCHR) p. 47.
5. Human Rights Watch . (2020). Human Rights Dimensions of COVID -19 Response. p. 1.
6. Barrie Sander , Jason Rudall (eds) . Symposium on COVID-19 and International Law . Opinio Juris Symposium. 2020. p. 42.
7. Barrie Sander, Jason Rudall (eds) . COVID-19 and International Law. Opinio Juris Symposium. Ibid. 2020. p. 51.
8. The right to health which deals with the right to the “highest attainable standard of physical and mental health.” It is a right of everyone, irrespective of citizenship or immigration status and wherever they may reside to healthcare systems, facilities, goods and services that are available, accessible, acceptable and of sufficient quality. JHRLP (2020) 68 –85 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 81
9. The United Nations Human Rights Office of t he High Commissioner and Inter - Parliamentary Union . Human Rights: Handbook for Parliamentarians No. 26 op. cit. 2016. page 50.
10. Dawood A, Bulmer E. Limitation Clauses: International IDEA Constitution -Building Primer 11 . 2nd ed . International IDEA, 2014. p. 7.
11. Olivier Nay . Can a virus undermine human rights? The Lancet Public Health . 2020; 5(5): E238–E239. Available at <https://www.thelancet.com>, (Last accessed on the 19th of May, 2020).
12. The UNAIDS Cosponsors Regional Group (UCRG) for Latin America and the Caribbean. (2020). Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID -19) and HIV: key issues and actions. Page 1 at 8. Available at: <https://iris.paho.org>, (accessed on the 18th May, 2020).
13. Nadeem S. Coronavirus covid-19: available free literature provided by various companies, journals and organizations around the w orld. Journal of Ongoing Chemical Research. 2020; 5(1): 7–13. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.372290.
14. OHCHR. (2020). COVID-19 and the rights of persons with disabilities: guidance. The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner . pp. 1–11. Available online at: <https://reliefweb.int>, (accessed on the 18th of May, 2020).
15. What you should know about COVID 19 to protect yourself and others. Department of Health and Human Services -USA. CDC. Available at: <https://www.cdc.gov>, (accessed on the 18th of May, 2020). (See Shrikrushna Subhash Unhale, Sanap et al. A Review on Corona Virus (COVID -19). World Journal of Pharmaceutical and Life Sciences (WJPLS). 2020; 6(4): 109–115. For the symptoms and treatments which include self -care and over -the-counter (OTC) medication and government restrictions of rights of the citizens.
16. Maryla Maliszewska, Aaditya Mattoo , Dominique van der Mensbrugghe . The potential impact of COVID -19 on GDP and trade: a preliminary assessment. World Bank Group, East Asia and the Pacific Region Office of the Chief Economist & Macroeconomics, Trade and Investment Global Practice . Policy Research Working Paper. 2020; 9211. pp. 1–26.
17. It affects human rights like the right to employment, education, freedom of movement, expression and the press, privacy, life, health care, etc.
18. It affects income levels, standards of living.
19. Over the period of March to April 2020, trade trends closely followed those for industrial production. Forty -three countries experienced a lower level of trade in goods. South Africa, India, Mexico, France and Italy are the five countries that suffered the highest reduction in trade volume over that period. Israel, China and Chile recorded an increase in trade. China further consolidated its path of rapid recovery.
20. The economic impact of COVID-19 on the industrial sector ultimately depends on how the continued containment measures and related restrictions affect manufacturing firms. The extent of firm’s productive capacities, their degree of integration in domestic a nd global production networks and type of market they serve are important factors determining the extent of the impact of the crisis on firm. Equally, the workforce of the firms too is affected. UNIDO (2020), Coronavirus: the economic impact, below.
21. UNIDO. (2020). Coronavirus: the economic impact . Available at: <https://www.unido.org/>, (accessed on the 15 July, 2020).
22. Dawood A, Bulmer E. Limitation Clauses: International IDEA Constitution -Building Primer 11, 2nd ed. International IDEA, 2014; page 9.
23. United Nations . (2020). COVID-19 and Human rights: we are all in this together, United Nations. p. 3. Available online at: <https://www.un.org>. (Accessed on the 19th May, 2020).
24. Statement by the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet . Tuesday 12 May, 2020. Virtual Debate “Human Rights of JHRLP (2020) 68 –85 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 82 Older Persons in the Age of COVID -19 and Beyond” with the High Commissioner for human rights and the new interdependent expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons . Available online at: . (Accessed on the 19th May 2020).
25. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. (2020). Coronavirus pandemic in the EU -Fundamental rights implications, Bulletin #1, European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, Luxembourg, page 7. These laws can derogate from some human rights but they need to be in force for a limited time and in a supervis ed manner.
26. UNAIDS. (2020). Rights in the time of COVID-19: Lesson from HIV for an effective, community -led response . UNAIDS Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS, G eneva, Switzerland. p. 7.
27. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. (2020). Coronavirus pandemic in the EU -Fundamental rights implications, Bulletin #1. op. cit. p. 7.
28. United Nations . (2020). Covid-19 and human rights: we are all in this together . op. cit. p. 2.
29. OHCHR. (2020). What are Human Rights? United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner . Available at: . (Accessed on 19th May, 2020).
30. United Nations. (2020). COVID-19 and human rights: we are all in this together, op.cit. page 3. See also O ttavio Marzocchi (2020). The impact of COVID-19 measures on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in EU. LIBE Committee Monitoring Group on Democracy. Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights. The Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs . European Parliament. Available online at: . Page 4, on the restriction of movement.
31. Human Rights Watch . (2020). Human Rights Dimensions of COVID -19 Response. p. 5.
32. Quarantine is the restriction of movement of healthy people who may have been exposed to the virus, usually for the incubation period before the symptoms or a positive test for the illness (at which point they would be put in isolation).
33. United Nations . (2020). COVID-19 and human rights: we are all in this together, above. p. 4.
34. The Siracusa Principles indicate that any such restrictions in the name of a ‘public health’ emergency must be ‘specifically aimed at preventing disease or injury or providing care for the sick and injured.’ The measures and restriction must be specifically aimed at realizing the right to health.
35. Barrie Sander, Jason Rudall (eds). (2020). COVID-19 and International Law: Opinio Juris Symposium. op. cit. p. 48.
36. Dawood A, Bulmer E. Limitation Clauses: International IDEA Constitution-Building Primer 11 . 2nd ed. International IDEA . 2014. p. 12.
37. The UNAIDS Cosponsors Regional Group (UCRG) for Latin America and the Caribbean. (2020). Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID -19) and HIV: key issues and actions. op. cit. pp. 1–8.
38. United Nations . (2020). COVID-19 and human rights: we are all in this together op. cit. p. 4.
39. Toby Mendel . (Undated). Freedom of Information as an Internationally Protected Human Right. p. 1.
40. International Council on Human Rights Policy. Beyond volunteerism: human rights and the developing international legal obligations of companies . International Council on Human Rights Policy. Versoix, Switzerland. 2002. p. 40.
41. The preamble of Law No. 2008/001 of 14 April, 2008 to amend and supplement some provisions of Law No. 96/6 of 18 January 1996 to amend the constitution of 2 June 1972.
42. The United Nations Refugee Agency . (2020). Cameroon: COVID-19 situation. UNHCR. pp. 1–4. Available at: <https://data2.unhcr.org> and . (Accessed on 18th May, 2020).
43. The United Nations Refugee Agency (2020). Cameroon: COVID -19 Situation, op. cit. JHRLP (2020) 68 –85 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 83
44. The UNAIDS Cosponsors Regional Group (UCRG) for Latin America and the Caribbean. (2020). Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID -19) and HIV: key issues and actions. op. cit. pp. 1–8.
45. The United Nations Refugee Agency . (2020). Cameroon: COVID -19 Situation. op. cit.
46. Viral lies: Misinformation and the coronavirus, art 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD, London , page 5 at 21. 2020.
47. Toby Mendel . (Undated). Freedom of information as an internationally protected human right. op. cit. p. 5.
48. Amnesty International. Protecting human rights defenders in the COVID-19 crisis. 2020. p. 1.
49. Amnesty International. (2020). Protecting human rights defenders in the COVID -19 crisis. Ibid. p. 3.
50. Toby Mendel. (2020). Restricting freedom of expression: standards and principles, background paper for meetings hosted by the UN special rapporteur on freedom of opinion and expression . Centre for law and democracy. p. 1.
51. Human Rights Watch . (2020). Human Rights Dimensions of COVID -19 Response. p. 3.
52. Thorbjorn Jagland. (2018). The state of democracy, human rights and the rule of law: role of institutions, threats to institutions. Report by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe. p. 31.
53. Ottavio Marzocchi. The impact of COVID- 19 measures on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in EU, LIBE Committee Monitoring Group on Democracy. Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights. European Parliament. 2020; p. 2.
54. Amnesty International . Undermining Freedom of Expression in China: The role of Yahoo, Microsoft and Google . UK: Amnesty International; 2016. p. 8.
55. Viral lies: misinformation and the coronavirus. Article 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD, 2020. London , p. 3 of 21.
56. Viral lies: Misinformation and the coronavirus, Article 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD. London , ibid, p. 3 of 21. 2020.
57. The Guardian Post Daily No. 1898 Newspaper Yaoundé . Friday May 22, 2020. Family drags CRTV to court for announcing Chemuta Banda died of COVID-19. p. 3.
58. An infodemic is defined as “an overabundance of information, some accurate and some not, that makes it hard for people to find trustworthy sources or reliable guidance when they need it.” Eliska Pirkova (2020) . Fighting Misinformation and Defending Free Expression during COVID -19: Recommendations for states. Access now, page 4. <https://www.accessnow.org>. (Accessed on the 25th May 2020).
59. Viral lies: Misinformation and the coronavirus. Article 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD, London , op. cit. page 5 at 21. 2020.
60. Art. 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 10th December 1948.
61. Art. 19.2 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966.
62. Art. 9 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (ACHPRs) 1981.
63. Art. 2 (1) of Law No. 90/52 of 19 December 1990 Relating to Freedom of Mass Communication. Amended and Supplemented by Law No. 99/11 of 20 July 1999.
64. Amnesty International . Undermining freedom of expression in China: the role of Yahoo, Microsoft and Google. UK: Amnesty International; 2016. p. 8.
65. Amnesty International . Undermining freedom of expression in China: the role of Yahoo, Microsoft and Google. Ibid, p.
66. Viral lies: Misinformation and the coronavirus, art 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD, London , op. cit. p. 7. 2020.
67. Viral lies: Misinformation and the coronavirus. Article 19-Free Word Centre, 60 Farringdon RD, London p. 8 at 21. 2020.
68. Section 45 of the constitution states that: “Duly approved or ratified treaties and international agreements shall, following their publication, override national laws, provided the other party implements the said treaty or agreement”. Concerning human rights, art. 65 makes the preamble part and parcel of the constitution. The preamble of the said constitution states that: “we, peop le of Cameroon … affirm our attachment to the fundamental freedoms enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Charter of the United Nations and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, and all dully ratified international conventions related thereto …”
69. Art. 19 of the ICCPRs, which sets out limits of permitted restrictions.
70. Toby Mendel . Restricting freedom of expression: standards and principles . Background paper for meetings hosted by the UN special rapporteur on freedom of opinion and expression . Centre for law and democracy. p. 1.
71. Ottavio Marzocchi. The impact of COVID- 19 measures on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in EU. LIBE Committee Monitoring Group on Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights, The Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs, European Parliament. Available online at: , page 7.
72. supreme.justia.com, visited on the 5th September 2020.
73. en.m.wikipedia.org, last visited on the 5th of September 2020.
74. This case was a landmark decision of the Supreme Court that helped to establish a fundamental “right to travel” in the U.S. law. See also the decision of the U.S. in the case of McCullen v. Coakley, 573 U.S. (2014). The Supreme Court justices agreed that a Massachusetts law prohibiting individuals from standing in a public sidewalk within 35 feet of an abortion facility was unconstitutional.
75. Youngabi B. Ngalim’s view in a debate organized by LEGA Guru Association LEGA on the theme: “COVID -19 and Freedom of Assembly. Online debate on whatsApp, held on the 3rd of September, 2020.
76. Victoria L Killion (Legislative Attorney). (2020). Freedom of association in the wake of coronavirus . Congressional research service legal sidebar. Available at: < https:crsreports.congress.gov> LSB10451 (last accessed on 29th May 2020) page 2 at 5.
77. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Coronavirus pandemic in the EU - Fundamental rights implications, Bulletin #1. op. cit, p. 12. 2020.
78. Deloitte. Privacy and data protection in the age of covid -19. Deliotte Belgium . p. 1. 2020.
79. See art. 7 -8 of the European Charter on Human Rights (ECHR).
80. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Coronavirus pandemic in the EU - fundamental rights implications. Bulletin #1, op. cit. p. 12. 2020.
81. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Coronavirus pandemic in the EU - Fundamental rights implications. Bulletin #1, ibid, p. 41. 2020.
82. See Occupational Health Services Recommendation. 1985 (No 171) of the ILO.
83. Art. 23 of the UDHR.
84. ILS contain specific guidance for ensuring decent work in the context of crisis response, including guidance that could be of relevance to the evolving COVID -19 outbreak. See for example, the Employment and Decent Work for Peace and Resilience Recommendation . 2017 (No 205).
85. International Labour Organization . ILO Standards and COVID -19 (coronavirus). (2020 FAQ) p. 4.
86. United Nations . (2020). COVID-19 and human rights: we are all in this together. op. cit, p. 8.
87. United Nations . COVID-19 and Human Rights: We are all in this together. 2020. p. 5.
88. Guidance Note on Education Systems’ Response to COVID-19. 2020. p. 1.
89. Human Rights Watch . COVID-19 and children’s rights. 2020. pp. 1–2. JHRLP (2020) 68 –85 © Law Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 85
90. UNHCR. Supporting the continuation of teaching and learning during the COVID - 19 pandemic: annotated resources for online learning . UNHCR/Hanah Maule - ffinch, Education Section. 2020. p. 3.
91. The preamble of 2008 Constitution of Cameroon.
92. UNHCR. Supporting continued access to education during COVID -19: emerging promising practices. 2020. p. 2.
93. Reimers F et al. Supporting the continuation of teaching and learning during the COVID -19 pandemic: Annotated resources for online learning . OECD, World Bank Group. 2020. p. 2.
94. IESALC. Covid-19 and higher education: today and tomorrow, impact analysis, policy responses and recommendations . 2020. p. 9.
95. International Association of Universities . The Impact of COVID -19 on higher education worldwide: resources for higher education institutions. IAU. 2020. p. 11.
96. Human Rights Watch . (2020). Human Rights Dimensions of COVID -19 Response. op. cit. p. 9.
97. Olivier Nay. Can a virus undermine human rights?” 2020; 5(5): E238–E239. The Lancet Public Health . Available at: . (Last accessed on the 19th of May, 2020).
98. Nadeem S. (2020). Coronavirus covid-19: available free literature provided by various companies . Journals and Organizations around the World . op. cit. pp. 7–13.
99. OHCHR. (2020). COVID-19 and the rights of persons with disabilities: guidance. The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner op. cit. pp. 1–11.
100. OHCHR. (2020). Covid-19 and the rights of persons with disabilities: guidance . The United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner op. cit. pp. 1–11.
101. United Nations. (2020). Policy brief: the impact of covid -19 on women . United Nations. Available at: . (Last accessed on 15 July, 2020). pp. 1–9.
102. The UNAIDS Cosponsors Regional Group (UCRG) for Latin America and the Caribbean. (2020). Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID -19) and HIV: key issues and actions. op. cit. pp. 1–8.
103. Maryla Maliszewska et al. (2020) . The Potential Impact of COVID -19 on GDP and Trade: a preliminary assessment. op. cit. pp. 1–26. This disease has killed the world’s economic, social, cultural, political activities.
104. Sander B , Rudall J (eds) . (2020). COVID-19 and International Law: Opinio Juris Symposium op. cit., p. 49.
105. Ottavio Marzocchi. (2020). The impact of COVID-19 measures on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in EU. LIBE Committee Monitoring Group on Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights . The Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs, European Parliament. Available online at: , (Last accessed on 23 June 2020) p. 1.
106. Sander B, Rudall J (eds). COVID-19 and International Law: Opinio Juris Symposium, op. cit., p . 128. See also Ottavio Marzocchi . The impact of COVID-19 measures on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in EU. (2020). op. cit. p. 4. Cite this Article Nchotu Veraline N. Minang, Rodrick Ndi, Carine Chamboli Oke, Mbinkar Emmanuel Mengndze. Face of Pandemics? Examining this Question through the Covid -19 Prism . Practice. 2020; 3(2): 68–85p.
