A Critical Assessment of Environmental Challenges Caused by Infrastructural Projects in Cameroon: A Legal Analysis of the Case of Lom Pangar Dam and Kumba Mamfe Road.
Keywords:
Environment-society-infrastructure-challenges-legal analysisAbstract
A healthy environment is indispensible for all forms of life on earth and on economic activities and growth. It is now factual that the environment is under serious threat caused by some types of investments causing the depletion of the ozone layer and irreversible destruction of the fauna and the flora. Among the environmental and social threatening activities we can mention the development of major infrastructures needed for development. Since Cameroon embarked on the much needed infrastructure such as roads and dams, so there is need for precautionary measures to strike a balance between the needs and risks for the environment and the human society. The legal requirement to protect both the environment as provided in both national legislation and international legal instruments is implemented by the production of an Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA). Consequently, this paper has as main objective to critically examine the environmental and socio-legal problems underlying the development of major investments projects in Cameroun with the case studies of the Lom Pangar Dam and the Kumba-Mamfe road projects. In order to realise the above objective, both doctrinal and empirical research methods were used. Empirical research consisted of field work during which data was collected. Doctrinal research involved essentially analysis of data collected with the help of documents at our disposal. We also used doctrine from secondary sources such as journals, articles, text books, websites and thesis that talk on the topic. We realised that, despite the existing laws, regulations and conventions, the Lom Pangar and Kumba- Mamfe infrastructural projects still result in many negative environmental and social effects such as: soil pollution, deforestation, destruction of secret sites, land expropriation, involuntary resettlement. It is thus evident that the authorities charged to ensure environmental protection to more effective and efficient in their assigned mission, should integrate the suggestions made in this work. This will go a long way to ameliorate environmental protection in the course of infrastructural projects
References
1. Tim Everett, Mallika lshwaran and Co, Defra Evidence and Analysis Series paper 2, Economic Growth and Environment, p. 5, March 2005.
2. John D. Shilling & Co, the Nexus between Infrastructure and Environment, the Evaluation Cooperation Group of the International Institutions, June 2007, p.5.
3. CCICED Annual General Meeting 2011 on Investment, Trade and the Environment our Framework of Analysis, p.2.
4. Danya Satter and Co, Conservation of the natural environment and social investment, Big Society Capital, Social Investment Insights Series April 2015, p.4.
5. Larsen Gaia and Athena, Striking the Balance between Investment and environment, ownership and accountability in social and environmental safeguard, WRI.Org, p.8.
6. Sylvia Bankobeza UNEP, International Environmental Law and Policy, p.10.
7. Rodrick Ndi, et al., Double Sale of One and The Same Piece of Land in Cameroon: The Legal Implications. National Journal of Real Estate Law . 2019; 2(1): 1 –12p. See also Egbe Samuel Egbe. The Concept of Community Forestry under Cameroonian Law, The African Society of International and Comparative Law, African Journal of International and Comparative Law, Vol. (2000), 12 Pt. 2.
8. Uwem EU . Environmental Degradation in the Niger Delta: A Critique of Existing Law for Curbing Degradation, in Nigerian Environmental Law Review vol. l, C.A Omaka (ed), 2007, Kingdom Age Publications 2007, at 67. See generally Ignation Prieto & Raul Noceda, Legal protection of the environment in developing countries, being the colloquium of the International Association of legal Science, (1974), p.27.
9. National Environmental Standards Regulation Enforcement Agency (Establishment Act) 2007. Section 37. See also OMOTOL A, J.A., Environmental law in Nigeria, the Caxton press (West Africa) limited Ibadan, (1990), p.1.
10. See article 4 (k) of Law No 96/12 of 5th August 1996 relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon. See also Muam Chi A., Cameroon environmental law withi n the framework of sustainable development ARIKA, Yaoundé, Cameroon ISBN, (2017), P.34.
11. African Development Bank (ADB), Integrated Environmental and Social Impact Assessment Guidelines, October 2003.
12. Klaus Topfer, Executive director, UNEP, The Training Ma nual on International Environmental Law, op-cit, p.183.
13. Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of wide Fauna and Flora (CITES), Convention on Migratory Species (CMS), Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as waterfowl habitat (ILM 1972), Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage (ILM 1972).
14. African Convention on the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (1968) 001 UNTS4, The Treaty on the Conservation and Sustainable Management of Forest ecosystems in Central African and to establish the Central African Forest Commission (COMIFAC).
15. Law No 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management, Law No 94/01 o f 20th January 1994 to lay down Forestry, Wildlife and Fishery Regulation.
16. Awung WJ. Underlying Causes of Deforestation and Forest Degradation in Cameroon . World Rainforest Movement.
17. Liviu Ameriei. Legal Compliance in the Forestry Sector: Case Study Cameroon, P.6, Final Report 7th January 2005.
18. Amarie L. Legal Compliance in the Forest Sector. Case study: Cameroon. 2005, Final Report, p.4.
19. Hunter D. and Co, International Environmental Law , 2 nd Edition, 2006, New York, Foundation press, p. 622.
20. Justice Nchunu Sama and Electha Bih Tawa, I U C N —ELC 2009 REDD —Legal Framework. Case study Cameroon, p.1.
21. Law No 94/01 of 20 th January Relating to Forestry, Wildlife and Fisheries which refers to th e 1994 Forestry law.
22. African Development Bank, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, Republic of Cameroon, Lom Pangar Hydroelectric Power. Summary of The Environmental and Social Impact Assessment, (ESIA), p.16.
23. African Development Bank, African Development Fund . Summary Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of the Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project . Cameroon Infrastructure Department July 2012, p.8
24. ADB, Ibid, p.10.
25. African Development Fund, Cameroon: Kumba -Mamfe Road Develop ment Project, Project Appraisal, p.19.
26. Law, Section 78(2) of the 18th December 2006.
27. Robinson Djeukam and Co, Wildlife Law as a tool for protecting threatened species in Cameroon, P.5, March 2012.
28. Oliver Njuh Fuo & Sama Miemuna Semie, Cameroons Environmental framework law and balancing of interest in socio-economic development in the balancing of interest in environmental law in Africa, June 27th 2012, Michael Faure &Willemien du Plessis (editors), Pretoria University law press, South Africa, World Bank, Washington DC, p.80.
29. ADB, Summary of ESIA of the Kumba-Mamfe road project, op-cit, p.12.
30. African Development Bank, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, Republic of Cameroon LPHP Summary of ESIA.
31. Dinah Shelton & Alexandre Kiss, Judicial Handbook on Environmental Law, op-cit, p.87.
32. ADB, Summary Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of The Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project in Cameroon, Ibid, p.7.
33. ADB, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, Lphp, Op-Cit, p.14.
34. African Development Fund, Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project, Project Appraisal Report, p.19.
35. Charles Linjap, I-Watch, Investment Watch Initiative. Appraising Development Effectiveness for the affected grassroots communities within the scope of the Lom Pangar Dam project . report on community-company dispute within the construction phase of the Lom Pangar Hydroelectric project, January 2014, p.18.
36. The centre for our Common Future, Down to Earth, 1995, in Hunter D., j. Salzman & Z. Durwood, op-cit, p.1147.
37. Klaus Topfer, The Training Manual on International Environmental law, op-cit, p.276.
38. Hunter D., J. Salzman and Z. Durwood, op-cit, p.1148.
39. Klaus Topfer, The Training manual on International Environmental law, op-cit, p. 111.
40. African Development Bank, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, Republic of Cameroon, Lom Pangar Hydroelectric Project, Summary of the Environmental and So cial Impact Assessment (ESIA), P 15.
41. African Development Bank (ADB), Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, Ibid p.16.
42. Dinah Shelton and Alexandre Kiss, United Nations Environmental Programme, Judicial Handbook on Environmental Laws, Introduction by Hon. Judge Christopher G. Weeramantry.
43. Klaus Topfer, op-cit p.92.
44. Summary Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of the Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project, op-cit p.7.
45. Charles Linjap, I-Watch, Investment watch initiative, p.18.
46. Salman M.A Salman and Daniel D. Bradlow, Regulatory Framework for Water Resources Management. A Comparative study p.32.
47. The Judicial handbook and Environmental law, p 65.
48. The World Bank, Law, Justice and Development series.
49. Klaus Topfer, op cit, p.245.
50. Dinah Shelto & Alexandre Kiss, op-cit p.65.
51. Ibid, p. 245.
52. The World Bank, Law, Justice and Development p. 2.
53. Earth Summit, Agenda 21, United Nations Programme of Action from Rio, UN, United Nations Publication 1993.
54. Klaus Topfer, The Training Manual op-cit, p.247.
55. Dinah Shelton & Alexandre Kiss, Judicial, op-cit, p.69.
56. Law No -98/005 of 14 th April 1998 laying down Regulations Governing Water Resources and provisions to safeguard the Principles of Environmental Management and Public Health Protection.
57. Ibid, article 2(1).
58. Ibid Article 9.
59. Lom Pangar Resume Environmental and Social Assessment, p.10.
60. ADB, Summary of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of the Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project, OP-CIT p.7.
61. ADB, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, LPHP, OP-CIT p.14.
62. ADB, Summary of Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of Kumba-Mamfe, op-cit, p.9.
63. Dinah Shelton & Alexandre Kiss, Judicial Handbook on Environmental Law, op-cit, p.115.
64. For example, article 261 of Camerooni an penal code of 2016 punishes any pollutant with an imprisonment term of fifteen days to six months and a fine of five thousands FCFA to one million FCFA or any of the two.
65. Ibid, article 261(b).
66. Summary Environmental and Social Impact Assessment of the Ku mba-Mamfe Road Development Project, op-cit, p.7.
67. ADB, Energy, Environmental and Climate Change Department, Republic of Cameroon, LPHP Summary of the ESIA, OP-CIT p.14.
68. European Investment Bank , Environmental and Social Handbook , Environment, climate and social office, Projects Directorate, version 9.0 of 02/12/2013.
69. Pierre-Etienne and Co, Land Investment accountability and law: Lessons from Cameroon, p.5.
70. United State Agency International Development (USAID) from the American People USAID, Country Profile, Property Rights and Resource Governance. Cameroon, p.6.
71. Pierre-Etienne and co op cit.
72. Fon Nsoh, Defending community land rights in Cameroon, tools and approach. p.2.
73. Ordinance No. 74–2 of 1974, section 7 of 6th July 1974 to Establish Rules Governing States lands.
74. Liz Alden Wily, Centre for environment and development/ FERN/ the Rainforest foundation UK. Whose Land is it? The status of customary land tenure in Cameroon, editor, Fd Fenton, printed by Redline print limited on recycled paper, February 2011, p.11.
75. Liz Alden Wily, Op-cit, p.4.
76. Ordinance No.74–1 of 1974 section 2 op-cit.
77. Ibid, Section 14(1).
78. USAID Country Profile op-cit.
79. Expropriation in Europe, January 2013, p.2.
80. Environnemental Résume, Environnemental et social op-cit, p.12.
81. African Development Bank, Government of Cameroon, Summary Environmental and Summary Impact Assessment of The Kumba -Mamfe Road Development Project In Cameroon, Infrastructure Development Oitc July 2012, op-cit, p.7.
82. Environmental and Social Policy, PR5: Land Acquisition, Involuntary Resettlement and Economic Displacement, p.1.
83. European Investment Bank op-cit., p.54.
84. ADB, Involuntary Resettlement Policy, November 2003, pp.17–18.
85. ADB, ibid, p.32.
86. Afshan Khawaja, OPCQC Za greb, Involuntary Resettlement, Operational Policy OP 4.12, May 2009, p.5.
87. ADB, Energy, Environmental and Climate Change Department, op.cit., p.19.
88. ADB, ibid, p.21.
89. European Investment Bank, Ibid, P. 63.
90. The European Investment Bank, ibid, p. 65.
91. Convention concerning the protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage 1972, Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, 2003 (UNESCO Intangible Heritage Conventional), Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of the Archeological Heritage of Europe,1992 (revised version of the convention adopted in 1969).
92. European Investment Bank op-cit, p.47.
93. Francesca Stavrakopoulou, Placing and Displacing the Dead in the Book of Kings , University of Exeter, Society of Biblical Literature San Diego, P. 1, November 2007.
94. This is a special day of the week set aside by a community not to go to the farm but to go and worship their gods in their shrine.
95. Liz Alden Wily, op-cit, p.56.
96. Sandra Belaude and Co, Land Legitimacy and Governance in Cameroon, Institute for Research and Debate on Governance and Columbia University school of International and Public Affairs, 2010, p.31.
97. Samuel Nguiffo (CED -AT) Cameroon, World Rainforest Movement (WRM), Infrastructure, development and natural resources in Africa: A few examples from Cameroon, posted on July 4th 2014 included in Bulletin203.
98. Order No 0832/1.15.1/MNUH/D000 OF 20 TH November 1987 laying Down the Bases for calculating the market value of the Buildings Affected by Expropriation for Public utility.
99. Georges Jay, Jean Paul Grandjean, Cameroon Network of Human Rights Organisations (CNHRO), Respect Of Human Rights On Sites Of Major Projects in Cameroon: Case Study of Lom Pangar, Mballam, Nkamuna and Mobilong, Observation Report, Yaoundé —Cameroon, op- cit, p.35.
100. EDC, Projet Hydroelectrique de Lom Pangar, Plan d’indemnisation et de Reinstallation, Ibid, P.18.
101. EDC, Projet Hydroelectrique de Lom Pangar, Plan d’indemnisation et de Reinstallation Ibid, P. 24.
102. Charles Linjap (Executive Manager Of Investment Watch), I -Watch, Investment Watch Initiative, Working For Inclusion, Report on Community -Company Dispute within the Construction Phase of the LPHP, P. 18.
103. ADB, Summary ESIA on Kumba-Mamfe road project, p.8.
104. ADB, ibid, p.22.
105. ADB, ibid, p.21.
106. ADB, Summary ESIA of the Kumba-Mamfe Road Development Project in Cameroon, ibid, P.7.
107. ADB, ibid, p.10.
108. ADB, Energy, Environment and Climate Change Department, op-cit.
