Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) as an Effective Tool for Environmental Sustainability under Cameroonian Law: Emerging Challenges and Legal Responses
Keywords:
Environment-EIA-Sustainability-Development-Management-Challenges-CameroonAbstract
It is worth noting that although infrastructural and developmental projects enhance economic growth of Cameroon, these projects have negative impacts on the environment and natural resources in which man greatly depend for livelihood. In this regard, to reconcile developmental exigencies and environmental protection and sustainability, there is the need for regulatory measures such as, EIA which will serve as an effective tool in that direction. Undoubtedly, the core purpose of EIA is to early integrate environmental and social considerations in the decision-making of proposed developmental projects in order to identify and mitigate potential negative impacts on the environment and human health. Regrettably, in spite of it’s well known purpose, the EIA processes have documented a number of weaknesses and challenges that impede its effective implementation and enforcement. Based on this fact findings, this article is intended to analyse the legal and regulatory instruments on EIA and the extent to which it have been helpful in providing better protection of the environment and sustainable development in Cameroon. In order to attain the above objectives, doctrinal and analytical methods have been adopted. This article therefore, concludes with some robust recommendations for filling the identified gaps. It is hope that this recommendation will go a long way in enhancing the implementation of regulations in order to dwindle the gap between theory and practice concerning EIA in Cameroon.
References
1. Kelvin, K.K., (2016), Factors Influencing the Implementation of Environmental Impact Assessment Recommendations on Commercial Projects. A Cas e of Nakuru Town, Nakuru County, Kenya, Masters Thesis, University of Nairobi, P.1.
2. [Morrison-Saunders, A., Marshal, R., & Arts, J., (2004), EIA Follow Up International Best Practice Principles , Karachi, Pakistan, p.5.
3. See Principle 17 of the 1992 Rio Declaration on Enviroment and Development.
4. See Article 14 (a) of the 1992 Convention on Biodiversity (CBD).
5. Section 17(1) of the 1996 Framework law on Environmental Management in Cameroon.
6. See Article 19 (2) of Law No. 1996 /12 of 5th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
7. Ashukem, J.C., (2016), A rights -based approach to foreign agro -investment governance in Cameroon, Uganda and South Africa, Ph.D Thesis, North-West University, Potchefstroom, P. 364-365.
8. Ibid, P. 362.
9. Decree No. 2005/0577/PM of 23 February fixing the modalities for the realisation of EIA of Cameroon.
10. Tamassang, C.F., and Sylvain N. A., (2018), «Environmental Impact Assessment under Cameroonian Law», In Environmental Law and policy in Cameroon-towards making Africa the tree of Life, Law and Constitution in Africa, Volume 37, p. 280.
11. See Article 7 of the 2013 Decre e on EIA of Cameroon.
12. See Section 2 (1), ibid.
13. Decree No. 2013/0171/PM to law down rules and procedure for conducting EIA.
14. Free, prior informed consent (FPIC) of local and indigenous peoples required for any activities affecting their rights to land, territories and resources.
15. The universal declaration on human right and the declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples compels states to consult and cooperate in good faith with the indigenous people concerned either directly or through their representatives/institutions in order to obtain their free, prior and informed consent before adopting and implementing legislative or administrative measures on the environment that may affect them.
16. Alemagi, D., Sondo, A. V., & Ertel, J., (2007), “Constraints to envir onmental impact assessment practice: A case study of Cameroon. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management”, vol: 9 (3), 357–380.
17. Nguene, F. R., et al., (2012), Role and Level of Stakeholders Involvement in the EIA Practice in Cameroon: Case of EIAs of the Upstream Energy Sector.
18. Bitondo, D., (2000), “Environmental assessment in Cameroon: state of the art”, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, vol: 18(10), p. 33–42. NJEL (2019) 24-44 © Law Journals 2019. All Rights Reserved Page 42
19. Foti, J., & Silva, L. D., (2010), A seat at the table: Including the poor in decisions for development and environment. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.
20. Dieudonne, A., et al., (2013), “Cameroon’s Environmental Impact Assessment Decree and Public Participation in Concession -Based Forestry: An Exploratory Assessment of Eight Forest -Dependent Communities”, 6, No. 10, p.2-3.
21. See Section 17 of the 1996 framework law on environmental management of Cameroon.
22. See Order No. 0069/MINEP of March 2005 prescribing the different categories of projects that would necessitate an ESIA.
23. Tamassang, C.F., and Sylvain N. A., (2018), «Environmental Impact Assessment under Cameroonian Law», In Environmental Law and policy in Cameroon-towards making Africa the tree of Life, Law and Constit ution in Africa, Volume 37, p. 279.
24. See Section 16 (2) of the 1994 forestry law and its decree of implementation.
25. See Article 110 of the forestry decree.
26. See IUCN Commission on Environmental Law (2004), Draft International Covenant on Environment and Devel opment, Third Edition: Updated Text, IUCN, 2004, p. 119.
27. Decree No. 2005/0577/PM du 23 Février 2005 Fixant les Modalités de Réalisation des Etudes d’impact Environmentale.
28. CRESA-Forét-Bois- a regional center affiliated to the University of Dschang.
29. Tamassang, C.F.,and Sylvain N. A., (2018), Op. Cit. p. 294.
30. Wood, C., (2002), Environmental Impact Assessment: a comparative review, 2ed Edition, Harlow, Prentice Hall.
31. Tamassang, C.F.,and Sylvain N. A., (2018), Op. Cit. p. 294.
32. Esther, E.N., (2019), «An analysis of environmental impacts of timber exploitation on indigenous communities’ land in Cameroon», In Law, Environmental and Africa, Law and Constitution in Africa, Vol. 38, 1st Edition, Nomos, Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden - Baden, Germanay, P. 700.
33. See Article 20 (1) of the 1996 framework law on environmental management of Cameroon.
34. Ashukem, J.C., (2019), «Public participation in environmental decision - making in Cameroon-myth or reality?», In Law, Environmental and Africa, Law and Constitution in Africa, Vol. 38, 1st Edition, Nomos, Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden - Baden, Germanay, p. 264–265.
35. Collins O., (2019), “The role of the Environment and Land Court in governing natural resources in Kenya”. In Law, Environmental and Africa, Law and Constitution in Africa, Vol. 38, 1st Edition, Nomos, Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden - Baden, Germanay, p.350.
36. Tamasang, C.F., (2019), Op. Cit. P.149.
37. See ECA/SDD/05/13 (2005), Review of the A pplication of Environmental Impact Assessment in Selected African Countries, ECA Printshop, Addis Ababa -Ethiopia, p.35–36.
38. Tekeu, J.C, (2004), Rapport sur la Pratique des Etudes d’Impact Environnemental (EIE) au Cameroun. Préparé pour la Commission Economi que pour l’Afrique de Nations Unies en Décembre 2004.
39. Cyrille Valence, N.K., (2013), “Public hearings in environmental and social impact assessment for energy sector projects in Cameroon”, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, Vol. 31, No. 1, 64– 73.
40. See CARFAD, (2009), Environmental Impact Assessment for the Forest Management Unit Nº 11 005, (CAFECO), Report, Eyumojock Subdivision, Manyu Division, South West Region, p.1–216.
41. Law No. 2016/007 of 12 July 2016 of Cameroon Penal Code.
42. See Article 79 of the Framework Law on Environmental Management in Cameroon.
43. Tamassang, C.F.,and Sylvain N. A., (2018), Op. Cit. p. 294.
44. République du Cameroun, (2017 ), Sessions du Comité départemental de suivi de la mise en œuvre des plans de gestion Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) as an Effective Tool Michel and Nkongho NJEL (2019) 24-44 © Law Journals 2019. All Rights Reserved Page 43 environnementale et sociale de SUDCAM- HEVA S.A. et Hydro Electrique de Mekin dans le Dja et Lobo. Rapport. Sangmélima.
45. Samuel, A.M., et al., (2019), Analysis of Chinese investments in non-forest environment affecting the forest land -use in Cameroon, study report, CED -iied- ukaid, p. 20.
46. Decree No.2013/0171/PM of February 14, 2013 laying down rules for conducting environmental and social impact studies (EIA Regulation).
47. Cameroon Oil Transportation Company (COTCO), Specific Environmental Impact Assessment (SEIA) for the Interaction between the Chad -Cameroon Pipeline Project and the Lom Pangar Dam Project Lom Pangar, Cameroon (Yaounde: COTCO, 2011).
48. Herakles Farms, Environmental and Social Impact Assessment prepared for SG Sustainable Oils Cameroon Ltd. (Yaoundé: Herakles Farms, 2011) [Herakles Farms EIA Report].
49. See article 14 of the 2005 EIA decree.
50. See article 15 of the 2005 EIA decree.
51. See article 9 of the 2005 EIA decree.
52. See Articles 10(2) and 11 of 1996 environmental code.
53. See Article 19 of Law N° 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
54. The Government of Cameroon created the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MINEF) in 1994. MINEF was split on December 2004 into two Ministries: Ministry of Forestry and Wildlife (MINFOF) and Ministry of Environment and Nature Protection (MINEP).
55. Decree No. 2012/431 of 01 October 2012, relating to the Ministry of Environment, Nature Protection and Sustainable Development.
56. Semie, M.S., (2017), Harnessing environmental justice to protect against land-grabbing in cameroon, Ph.D Thesis, Ottawa, Canada, p. 200.
57. See Article 8(2) of the 1996 environmental code.
58. CyrilleValence, N.K., (2013), “Public hearings in environmental and social impact assessment for energy sector projects in Cameroon”, Impact As sessment and Project Appraisal, Vol. 31, No. 1, 64–73.
59. See Article 10 of Law N°. 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
60. See Articles 10(2) and 16(2), ibid.
61. See Article 13 of 2013 EIA regulation of Cameroon.
62. See Article 11(1) of Law N°. 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
63. This projects includes the following: •Project of modification of installation that underwent a detailed EIA study, •Abstraction of rural water and real estate projects with 50–100 apartments, •periodic maintenance of roads in rural areas, construction of thermal centres and other combustible installation with a capacity of less than 2 megawatts, •Project requiring the reclamation of land from water on a lower scale, •Water irrigation project with irrigation surface between 100 and 500 hectares, •Aquaculture with surface area superior to 50 hectares, •Exploitation of community forest, •Artisanal and small - scale mining, •Industries responsible for the transportation of forest products on a smaller scale, •Artisanal leather industry, •Industrial exploitation of mineral water, • Installation for the repair of aircraft, •Installation for the repair of rail way materials and, •Assembly of vehicles and machines
64. They includes : •Establishments classifies as dangerous, unhygienic and obnoxious of the first category • Dams; •Canalization, aqueduct and other installations for the regulation of water: 100,000 meters cube/day as output •Waste recycling units; •Installation for the treatment of domestic waste with a capacity greater than 50 tonnes per day; •Large hospital units, large educational and research units ; •Community and sports infrastructure and other civil engineering Works ; •Economic infrastructure ( construction and rehabilitation of roads, motorways, thermal centers and other combustible installation with capa city of more than 2 megawatts • Agricultural exploitation with NJEL (2019) 24-44 © Law Journals 2019. All Rights Reserved Page 44 surface a rea greater than 100 Hectares ; •Water irrigation project with irrigation surface greater than 500 hectares with river water ; •Agro-forestry projects with surface area gr eater or equal to 50 hectares; •Slaughter-house, shipping yard, tourist ind ustry, and industrial fishing ; •Exploration and exploitation of hydrocarbons, crude oil and installation of gasification and liquefaction.
65. See Article 8 of the 2013 Decree on EIA.
66. See Article 11 of Law N°. 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
67. EIA Regulation, supra, article 12.
68. EIA Regulation, supra, article 9.
69. Environmental Code, supra, article 9(e).
70. EIA Regulation, supra, article 11.
71. EIA Regulation, supra, article 14.
72. EIA Regulation, supra, article 16.
73. See Article 27 (3) of Law N°. 96/12 of 5 th August 1996 Relating to Environmental Management in Cameroon.
74. World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) Our Common Future, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987.
75. United Nations, Achieving Sustainable Development and Promoting Development Cooperation: Dialogues at the Economic and Social Council, New York, United Nations, 2008.
76. Bond, A., et al., (2012), “Sustainability assessment: The State of the Art” (2012) 30 Impact Assessment and Project: Appraisal, p. 53–62.
77. Gibson, R. B., (2006), Sustainability- based assessment criteria and associated frameworks for evaluations and decisions: theory, practice and implications for the Mackenzie Gas Project Joint Review Panel.
78. Pope, J., A. Morrison -Saunders, and D. Annandale, (2004), “ Conceptualising sustainability assessment”, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, vol. 24(6), 595–616.
79. Waas, T., et al ., (2014), “Sustainability Assessment and Indicators: Tools in a Decision-Making Strategy for Sustainable Development”, Sustainability, vo.6, p.5512–5534.
80. Weaver, A., et al., 2008), “Contributing to sustainability as an environmental impact assessment practitioner”, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, vo. 26(2), p.91–98.
81. Sama, N. J., (2010), Criminal Law and Environment, Prosecutors, Inspectors and NGOs in Cameroon, p.6.
82. Ness, B. et al., (2007), “Categorising tools for sustainability assessment” , 60, Ecol. Econ., p.498–508.
83. Grace, W., and Pope, J., (2005), “Sustainability assessment -issues of process, policy and governance” pap er for presentation to the International experience and perspectives in S trategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) of the IAIA, Prague, Czech Republic, p.26–30.
84. Tamasang, C.F., (2019), “ Forests, forest rights, benefit-sharing and climate change implications under C ameroonian law”, In Law, Environmental and Africa, Law and Constitution in Africa, Vol. 38, 1st Edition, Nomos, Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden - Baden, Germanay.
85. See Decree No. 94/259/PM of 31 May 1994.
86. Mfor, D.A., (2017), “Corporations and human rights in Cameroon: A comment on the struggle to economise future environment (SEFE) V. S.G. Sustainable Oils Cameroon ( LTD.) and Dr. Timi Isidore”, Juridis Pé riodique N o. 109, P. 133–146. Cite this Article Mbetiji Mbetiji Michel, Ayuk Macbert Nkongho. Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) as an Effective Tool for Environmental Sustainability under Cameroonian Law: Emerging Challenges and Legal Responses . National Journal of Environmental Law. 2019; 2(2): 24–44p.
