The Political, Economical and Psychological Impact of Electoral Freebies in Indian Politics: A Critical Study

Authors

  • Janees Rafiq Student

Keywords:

Freebies, Populist, Welfare Program, Marginalized, Electoral, Disparities

Abstract

India has a long history of supporting social welfare programmes that attempt to increase the economic security of the country's most vulnerable citizens. However, these social payments are usually labelled as "handouts" or "giveaways", often promised or delivered for political objectives, which is widely seen as manipulative and exclusively aimed to sway voters. In addition to discouraging initiative and entrepreneurship, the extensive distribution of different welfare resources places a financial strain on the public purse, particularly in terms of trade-offs with long-term development efforts. There is a lot of dispute about how significant a role these freebies play in Indian politics. Freebies are the offering of products or services by political parties to the people with the main aim of winning political support and votes, and are also known as populist welfare programmes or electoral incentives. Food, clothes, and shelter are only a few examples; other options include technological goods, help paying off agricultural loans, and free or low-cost housing. Those in favour of such handouts say they help reduce economic disparities and empower disadvantaged groups. However, detractors claim that they promote a culture of dependency, stunt economic progress, and undermine democratic norms and sound budgeting. This study examines these giveaways in Indian politics from several angles, looking at their good and bad repercussions. The study also provides a complete methodology for assessing the effect of these giveaways on India's state welfare programmes, while drawing attention to the major concerns in the current discussion over them.

References

Pandey M, Sjöberg MEM. Electoral Competition, Party Strategies, and the Distributive Politics of Public Goods. Am Polit Sci Rev.

Kenneth Bo Nielsen. Populism and Welfare Politics in India. In: Narendar Pani, Virginius Xaxa, editors. Freebies and Populist Policies in India.

Srinivas Rao Y, Prabhakar K. Freebies in Indian Politics: A Critical Analysis. Journal of Social and Economic Development.

Jeyaranjan J, Suriyakumar KC. The Politics of Freebies: A Study of Tamil Nadu.

123(7) obtain or procuring the assistance of a person in the service of the government of RP Act, 1951 VI.123(8) booth capturing of RP Act, 1951.

AIR 1960MP 362 44Subba Rao vs. k. Bhrahmananda Reddy, 1967 Doabia’s Election Cases 1998.

Anand Ballabh Kafaltiya. Democracy and Election Laws 179. 2nd Edn. Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications; 2007.

Staff Reporter. Corruption, freebies pushing up state debt’s, India. [Online]. Available at: thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-tamilnadu/corruption-freebies-pushing-upstatesdebt/article5701603.ece (modified on February 18, 2014)

Pandey JN. The Constitutional Law 409. 49th Edn. Allahabad: Central Law Agency; 2012.

Election commission of India. [Online]. Available at: http://eci.nic.in/eci_main/MCC-ENGLISH_28022014.pdf (Last visited on 10th September, 2015)

Supra 10n.

Ajai Sreevatsan. (2015 Mar 30). Freebies pose a threat to Tamil Nadu’s fiscal health, India. [Online]. available at: thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/freebies-pose-a-threat-to-tamil-nadus-fiscal health/article7046311.ece?ref=relatedNews (Last modified on March 30, 2015)

HS, Doabia. Law of elections and election petitions 1850. 4th Edn. Delhi: LexisNexis; 2015.

Venkatesh MR. (2011 Mar 28). How Tamil Nadu's freebie culture is killing its economy. [Online]. available at: http://www.rediff.com/business/slide-show/slide-show-1-how-tamil-nadus-freebie-culture-is-killingitseconomy/20110328.htm (modified on March 28, 2011)

Iqbal Singh vs Gurudas Singh AIR 1976 SC 27.

Shankar IAS Academy. (2017). FRBM panel recommends new set of targets. [online] Iasparliament.com. Available from: https://www.iasparliament.com/article/frbm-panel-recommends-new-set-of-targets

Mahajan K, Singh Y. Election Manifesto: Legal Reality or Illusion. TNNLU Law Review. 2018;1.

ECI. Election Manifestos. [Online]. <https://eci.gov.in/election-manifestos/> accessed on 4th September, 2023

Oxford dictionary, India [Online]. <http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/> accessed on 4th September, 2023

Divya Chandrabhu. (2016 May). Amma canteens feed several Chennaiites on polling day. [Online]. Times of India. <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/elections-2016/tamil-nadu-elections-2016/news/tamil-nadu-election-amma-canteens-feed-chennaiites-on-polling-day/articleshow/52293286.cms> accessed on 6th September, 2023

Iqbal Singh vs. Gurdas Singh, AIR 1976 SC 27 (1976), 3 SCC 284.

TOI. (2015 Jan 31). Delhi Elections 2015: AAP MANIFESTO. [Online]. Times of India. <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/delhi-elections-2015/top-stories/delhi-elections-2015-aap-manifesto-top-15-highlights/articleshow/46075127.cms> accessed on 7th September, 2023

(2013) 9 SCC 659.

Vishal Rambani. (2022 Oct 20). Freebies’ Fiscal Cost: Punjab Doles Out `50-cr Daily Power Subsidy. [Online]. Hindustan Times. <https://www.hindustantimes.com/ cities/chandigarh-news/freebies-fiscal-cost-punjab-doles-out-rs-50-cr-daily-powersubsidy-101666288240096.html> accessed on 8th September, 2023

Abhijit Ahaskar. (2020). 79% students in India use smartphones for online learning, says report | Mint. [online] mint. Available from: https://www.livemint.com/news/india/79-indian-students-rely-on-smartphones-for-online-learning-says-report-11598524750207.html

Sevanti Ninan. (2019 Oct). Modi Wanted to End MGNREGS. Now It’s His Only Tool to Ride Through Slowdown. [Online]. The Print. <https://theprint.in/opinion/ narendra-modi-mgnregs-slowdown-indian-economy-rural-employment-schemejobs/312580/> accessed on 8th September, 2023

Sandip Das. (2022 Nov 21). No Decision Yet on Extending PMGKAY Beyond Dec: Food Subsidy to Cross Rs 3 Trillion This Fiscal. [Online]. The Financial Express. <https://www.financialexpress.com/economy/no-decision-yet-on-extendingpmgkay-beyond-dec-food-subsidy-to-cross-rs-3-trillion-this-fiscal/2865944/> accessed on 8th September, 2023

Quraishi SY. (2022 Sep 7). Revdi Culture Debate: Why We Need Freebies in India. [Online]. The Indian Express. <https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/ columns/revdi-culture-debate-why-we-need-freebies-in-india-8135143/> accessed on 9th September, 2023

Aiyar Y.( 2022 Aug 9). Freebie, Subsidy, Compensation: Let’s Reset the Terms of Debate. [Online]. Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/freebie-subsidy-compensation-lets-reset-terms-debate-8078602/

Feroz Varun Gandhi. (2022 Aug 24). Are Freebies a Way to Mask State Inaction? [Online]. The Hindu. <https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/are-freebies-a-wayto-mask-state-inaction/article65800862.ece> accessed on 9th September, 2023

Mooij J. Welfare Policies and Politics: A Study of Three Government Interventions in AP. Working Paper. London: Overseas Development Institute; 2002 Sep. [Online].

Pillay DPK, Manoj Kumar TK. Food Security in India: Evolution, Efforts and Problems. Strateg Anal. 2018; 42(6): 595–611.

Shilpy Sinha. (2012 Aug 29). Govt-Sponsored Schemes: Meant for Poor, But Beyond Their Reach. [Online]. Economic Times. <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ wealth/insure/govt-sponsored-schemes-meant-for-poor-but-beyond-their-reach/ articleshow/15914642.cm> accessed on 9th September, 2023

Pallavi Choudhuri, Sonalde Desai, Santanu Pramanik. (2022 Jun 13). Urban Exclusion: Rethinking Social Protection in India in the Wake of Covid-19. [Online]. Ideas For India. <https://www.ideasforindia.in/topics/poverty-inequality/urban-exclusion-of-social-protection-programmes-in-india-in-the-wake-of-thepandemic.htm> accessed on 9th Septmber, 2023

Reserve Bank of India. (2022 Jul). RBI Bulletin. [Online]. <https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/ BS_ViewBulletin.aspx?Id=21070> accessed on 9th September, 2023

Sudipto Mundle, Satadru Shikdar. (2020 Sep 4). Subsidies, Merit Goods, and Fiscal Space – II. [Online]. Ideas For India. <https://www.ideasforindia.in/topics/ macroeconomics/subsidies-merit-goods-and-fiscal-space-ii.htm> accessed on 9th September, 2023

Neha Shah, Atman Shah. (2022 Sep 2). On Freebies: We Are Asking the Wrong Questions. The Indian Express. [Online]. <https://indianexpress.com/ article/opinion/columns/on-freebies-we-are-asking-the-wrong-questions-modikejriwal-8125813/> accessed on 10th September, 2023

PTI. (2022 Jan 31). Expenditure on Social Services Rises 9.8 pc to Rs 71.61 lakh crore in FY22: Eco Survey. [Online]. Economic Times. <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ news/economy/indicators/expenditure-on-social-services-rises-9-8-pc-to-rs-71-61- lakh-crore-in-fy22-eco-survey/articleshow/89243343.cms> accessed on 10th September, 2023

Nanda Prashant K. (2022 Jan 31). Economic Survey 2022: Social Service Spending Increases to 8.6% of GDP; Health Gains, Education Flat. [Online]. Money Control. <https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/economy/economic-survey2022-social-service-spending-increases-to-8-6-of-gdp-health-gains-educationflat-8009571.htm> accessed on 10th September, 2023

Reserve Bank of India. (2021 Nov 30). Fiscal Position of the State Governments. [Online]. <https://rbi.org.in/Scripts/PublicationsView.aspx?id=20833#C> accessed on 10th September, 2023

Reserve Bank of India. Fiscal Position of the State Governments.

Nivedita V. (2022 Aug 26). It’s Complicated - The Freebie Debate Explained. [Online]. Business Line. <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/news/national/its-complicatedthe-freebie-debate-explained/article65787138.ece> accessed on 10th September, 2023

Shankkar Aiyar. (2022 Jul 30). What is a Freebie, Whose Money is it Anyway? [Online]. New Indian Express. <https://www.newindianexpress.com/opinions/columns/ shankkar-aiyar/2022/jul/30/what-is-a-freebie-whose-money-is-it-anyway-2482388. htm> accessed on 10th September, 2023

Vivek Kaul. (2022 Aug 26). The Ultimate Freebie Explainer: Everything You Always Wanted to Know, But Were Too Afraid to Ask. [Online]. News Laundry. accessed on 10th September, 2023

Avani Kapur. (2019 Jun 25). Centre Gives a Lot of Money to States for Social Welfare. A Good Policy, But Only on Paper. [Online]. The Print. <https://theprint.in/opinion/ centre-gives-a-lot-of-money-to-states-for-social-welfare-a-good-policy-but-onlyon-paper/253685/> accessed on 11th Septemner, 2023

Thomas Issac TM. (2022 Sep 20). Fiscal Federalism and Hullabaloo Around Freebies. [Online]. New Indian Express. <https://www.newindianexpress.com/ opinions/2022/sep/20/fiscal-federalism-and-hullabaloo-around-freebies-2499924. html#:~:text=A%20key%20provision%20 of%20the,revenue%20 expenditure%20of%20the%20states.> accessed on 11th September, 2023

Pallavi Nahata. (2022 Jan 10). Budget 2022: The Government’s Burgeoning Subsidy Bill. [Online]. Bloomberg Quint. <https://www.bqprime.com/business/budget2022-the-governments-burgeoning-subsidy-bill> accessed on 11th September, 2023

Rajiv Nayan Chaturvedi. (2022 Sep 5). BJP vs Opposition: No Let-Up In The Politics Of Freebies Vs Welfare Schemes Debate. [Online]. Outlook. accessed on 11th September, 2023

Kaul V. (2022 Aug 26). The Ultimate Freebie Explainer: Everything You Always Wanted to Know, But Were Too Afraid to Ask. [Online]. https://www.newslaundry.com/2022/08/26/the-ultimate-freebie-explainer-everything-you-always-wanted-to-know-but-were-too-afraid-to-ask

Rohit Kumar, Sumanpreet Kaur. Freebies Politics in India and Its Political, Economic, and Psychological Impact on Voters. IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science (IOSR-JHSS). 2022 Dec; 27(12): 04–10. [Online]. accessed on 12th September, 2023

Supra 50n.

Ibid.

Supra 50n.

Ibid.

RBI report, June 2022, State Finances: A Risk Analysis.

Ibid.

RBI report, June 2022, State Finances: A Risk Analysis.

Meera Emmanual. (2023 Mar). Freebie culture has fostered laziness among the people of Tamil Nadu. [Online]. Bar & Bench. <https://www.barandbench.com/news/litigation/freebie-culture-makes-people-lazy-corrupt-practice-madras-high-court> accessed on 12th September, 2023

Navjeevan Gopal. (2021 Nov 25). What AAP’s ‘Rs 1,000 to all women’ will cost Punjab. [Online]. Indian Express. <https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/what-aaps-rs-1000-to-all-women-will-cost-punjab-elections-7638089/> accessed on 12th September, 2023

Kay Atanda, Alexandru Cojocaru. (2021 Mar 31). Shocks and Vulnerability to Poverty in Middle-Income Countries. [Online]. World Bank Blogs.

Sharad Raghavan TCA. (2022 Oct 7). Covid Reversed Poverty Decline, Made 7.1 cr People Poor, Says World Bank. At Least 1/3 From India. [Online]. The Print. <https://theprint.in/india/covid-reversed-poverty-decline-made-7-1-cr-peoplepoor-says-world-bank-at-least-1-3-from-india/1157031/> accessed on 15th September, 2023

Outlook. (2019 Oct 9). India Among Worst Performing BRICS Nations On Global Competitiveness Index: WEF. [Online]. <https://www.outlookindia.com/website/ story/india-news-india-among-wo> accessed on 15th September, 2023

Economic Times. (2020 Dec 17). India Ranks 131 in United Nations’ Human Development Index. [Online]. <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/indiaranks-131-in-united-nations-human-development-index/articleshow/79763286.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst> accessed on 15th September, 2023

Mayuri Gupta. (2022). Freebies Debate Highlights the Limits of Judicial Overreach. NewsClick. [online] Available at: https://www.newsclick.in/Freebies-Debate-Highlights-Limits-Judicial-Overreach

Ghosh K. (2022). The Freebies Debate: Should Supreme Court Engage With A Subject That Falls Outside Its Purview? [online] Outlook Business & Money. Available from: https://business.outlookindia.com/news/the-freebies-debate-should-supreme-court-engage-with-a-subject-that-falls-outside-its-purview--news-217151

Jha M. (2022 Oct 7) Election Commission’s Proposal on Freebies and Election Promises Raises Questions of Institutional Overreach. [Online]. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/ columns/election-commission-proposal-on-freebies-promises-raises-questions-of-institutional-overreach-8193578/

Devasahayam MG. (2022 Aug 8). India’s ‘Freebie Politics’: Why SC’s ‘Expert Panel’ May Be of Little Help. [Online]. https://www.thequint.com/opinion/indias-freebie-politics-why-scs-expert-panel-may-be-of-little-help

TM Thomas Issac. (2022 Sep 20). Fiscal Federalism and Hullabaloo Around Freebies. [Online]. New Indian Express. <https://www.newindianexpress.com/ opinions/2022/sep/20/fiscal-federalism-and-hullabaloo-around-freebies-2499924. html#:~:text=A%20key%20provision%20 of%20the,revenue%20 expenditure%20of%20the%20state> accessed on 15th September, 2023

Published

2023-12-04

How to Cite

Rafiq, J. (2023). The Political, Economical and Psychological Impact of Electoral Freebies in Indian Politics: A Critical Study. Journal of Constitutional Law and Jurisprudence, 7(1), 1–24. Retrieved from https://lawjournals.celnet.in/index.php/Jolj/article/view/1445