Federalism in India: A Comprehensive Analysis of its Evolution, Features, and Controversies
Keywords:
Federalism, India, Constitution, Central Government, State Government, Evolution, Features, Controversies, Judiciary, Division of PowersAbstract
India's federalism offers a distinctive form of government that is distinguished by the division of authority between the federal and state administrations. This article provides a thorough examination of the evolution, features, and controversies surrounding federalism in India. Starting with its historical foundation, the conversation looks at the core characteristics of the federal system, such as the Constitution's primacy, the division of powers, its inflexibility, and the function of an independent judiciary. The article explores the merits and demerits of federal government, highlighting its suitability for diverse countries like India. Additionally, it analyzes the evolution of federalism in India, tracing its constitutional history from colonial rule to the present day. Through a detailed examination of legal precedents and scholarly discourse, the article sheds light on the complexities and nuances of Indian
federalism, addressing the ongoing debates and differing perspectives on its nature and functioning.
References
See, Dicey, Law of the Constitution, (1952), p. 138; see also Federalism; Problems and Methods, IV International Bulletin of Social Science, (1952), p. 72: Bowie, Problems of Federalism, (19872), p.11; Wheare, Federal Government, (1953), p. 14; Schwartz, American Constitutional Law, (1955), p. 738; Friedrich & Bowie, Studies in Federalism, (1957), p. 426; Mc Whinney, Comparative Federalism (1962), p. 131; Sawer, Modern Federalism, (1969), p. 79; Ricker, Federalism: Origin, Operation, Significance (1964), p. 76; Livingstone, Federalism and Constitutional Change (1956), p.174; Jain, Federal Grants-in-aid in the USA (1956), p. 79; Jain, Some Aspects of Indian Federalism
, (1979), p. 644; Jain, “Federalism in India”, VI JILI, 355 (1965), p. 355; Alice Jacob, “Centre-State Governmental Relations in the Indian Federal System”, X JILI, (1968), p. 583; S.N. Jain, “Freedom of Trade and Commerce and Restraints on the State Power to Tax Sale in the Course of Inter-State Trade and Commerce, X JILI, (1968), p.586; M.P. Jain, Indian Federalism – A Background Paper in ILI, Constitutional Development since Independence, (1974), pp.205-254; Setalvad, Union and State Relationship under the Indian Constitution (1974), p. 214
Sower, Modern Federalism (1969), p. 189
Wheare, Federal Government, 4th Edn., (1963), p. 424
M.P. Jain, Indian Constitutional Law, 4th Edn., (1993), p. 662
Ibid
(2007) 6 SCC, p.236
AIR 1977 Madras 1920
K.C. Wheare, Modern Constitution, (1952), p.27
K.P. Krishnashetty, The Law of Union State Relation and Indian Federalism (1981), p.447
Ibid at p.28
C.H. Alexandrowicz, Constitutional Developments in India, (1957), pp.158-159.
Ibid at p.159
Ibid at p.55
Sir Ivor Jennings, Some Characteristics of the Indian Constitution (1953), p.1; see also M.P. Jain, Federalism in India (1964), p. 17.
Ibid at p.552
Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution – Cornerstone of a Nation (1966), pp.186-187.
W.H. Morris – Jones, The Government and Politics of India 2nd Edn., (1967), pp.141-144.
U.K. Hicks, F.G. Carnell and Others, Federalism and Economic Growth in Under Developed Countries (1963), p.53.
Wheare, Modern Constitution, 2nd Edn. (1966), p. 142
Lecture at Public Forum, Bandaranaike Centre for International Studies, Colombo, Sri Lanka on September 13, 2004
A.H.J. Greenidge, A Handbook of Greek Constitutional History (1914), p.220
A.V. Dicey, Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution 8th Edn. (1927) p. 126
See A.T. Mason and V.M. Beaney, The Supreme Court in a Free Society (1959), p.71.
K.C. Wheare, Modern Constitution, 3rd Edn., (1963), p. 74
Ibid
Bora Laskin, “Reflections on the Canadian Constitution after the First Century”, xlv Can.Bar Rev., (1967) p.401
G.N. Singh, Landmark in Indian Constitutional and National Development, (1989) p. 73.
Jennings, Some Characteristics of the Indian Constitution, (1953), p. 56
Wade and Philips, Constitutional Law, 4th edn., (1972) p. 4
Section 45A of the Government of India Act, 1915, as inserted by the Government of India Act, 1919
Report of the Joint Parliamentary Committee, (1934) Vol. I, pp. 232-238.
M.V. Pyle, Constitutional History of India, p. 24
Dr.J.N. Pandey, Constitutional Law of India, 41st edn., (2004), p. 9
Ibid at p. 34
(1978) 11 SCJ 190
AIR 1961 SC 1461; See also I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu and others, (2007) SC 845; Re Berubari v. Union of India, AIR 1960 SC 845; Karunanidhi v. Union of India, AIR 1979 SC 898; Vijay Kumar Sharma v. State of Karnataka, (1990) 2 SCC 56; Greater Bombay Corporation Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex Ltd., (2007) 6 SCC; State of West Bengal v. Union of India, AIR 1963 SC 1241
CAD, Vol. XI, p. 976.
